Jay Dyer Connects the Dots for Taylor Marshall Followers

Jay Dyer Connects the Dots for Taylor Marshall Followers

Michael shows how Taylor Marshall’s views may lead to a radical version of Eastern Orthodoxy. He does so by reviewing Orthodox apologist Jay Dyer, who connects the dots for Marshall’s fans. In the process, he shows why both the Taylor Marshall and Jay Dyer positions are wrong.

00:00 Introduction
02:07 Jay Dyer’s background as a Rad Trad
05:17 Dyer on Pope Francis and evangelism
07:29 Dyer and Rad Trads on the Latin Mass
10:15 Eastern Orthodoxy and the indefectibility of the Roman see
14:11 Jay Dyer’s inconsistency on papal infallibility
18:05 The criteria of papal infallibility in Vatican I
19:00 What is indefectibility?
21:57 The occupant of the see vs. the see itself
23:32 Radical Traditionalists on Vatican I
26:05 Rad Trads and La Salette
28:00 Breakaway groups in Eastern Orthodoxy
30:11 Jay Dyer on papal elections
32:20 Rad Trads who are ripe for the picking
33:24 Jay Dyer on mental gymnastics
34:05 Dyer claims Rad Trads leads to alcoholism
36:00 Why the pope restricted the Latin Mass
38:40 Dyer and Rad Trads on the pope and the New World Order
42:00 Dyer on heretical popes
46:20 Taylor Marshall on Pope Francis as a heretic
47:53 Double-talk of Jay Dyer
50:40 The inconsistency of Dyer on the filioque
52:40 Orthodox at war with each other?
54:20 The East accepted the papal claims of Vatican I?
57:00 Jay Dyer’s rash judgement against Trent Horn
58:11 Muslims and Christians worship the same God?
1:01:00 Patriarch Kirill on Muslims worshipping the Christian God
1:03:10 Jay merely asserting his position
1:04:20 Jay’s poor research
1:05:20 Answering superchats

The video reviewed may be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPPftBpwavs&t=637s&ab_channel=DyerClips

The video Michael references about the fragmentation of Eastern Orthodoxy may be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJnOtaN3VCY&t=3195s&ab_channel=Reason%26Theology

Michael on Pints with Aquinas: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JYFOVHROCg&t=2579s&ab_channel=PintsWithAquinas

Michael’s commentary on Traditionis Custodes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zOF2QKMd2ZU&ab_channel=Reason%26Theology

Michael responding to Fr. Andrew Damick on papal infallibility: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4GjMt27hj_Q&t=1s&ab_channel=Reason%26Theology

Michael’s response to Fr. Lawrence Farley on an Orthodox Magisterium: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QswDBisTRWk&t=409s&ab_channel=Reason%26Theology

Pope Francis on Evangelism vs. Proselytism: https://youtu.be/m37_gWkGFzg

#orthodox #easternorthodoxy #orthodoxy #catholic #pope #theology #debate

Leave a Reply